Rebaudioside side effects, safety, benefits
September 1 2017
Rebaudioside A is a sweet tasting steviol glycoside extracted and purified from Stevia rebaudiana (Bertoni). It appears to be safe to use by humans and no significant side effects have yet been reported.
Overview: the history, technical function
and safety of rebaudioside A, a naturally occurring steviol glycoside, for use
in food and beverages.
Food Chem Toxicol. 2008.
Steviol glycosides can currently be used as a food
ingredient in only a handful of countries. Questions on specifications, safety
and special population effects have prevented steviol glycosides from obtaining
a legal status permitting their use as a sweetener in most countries. A set of
papers reporting results of research studies and reviews has been compiled in
this Supplement to definitively answer unresolved questions. Specifically,
recently completed studies on the general and reproductive toxicity of
rebaudioside A corroborate studies carried out with purified steviol glycosides
demonstrating safety at high dietary intake levels. Comparative metabolism
studies provide further affirmation of the common metabolic pathway for all
steviol glycosides and the common metabolism between rats and humans. Finally,
clinical studies provide further evidence that purified rebaudioside A has no
effect on either blood pressure or glucose homeostasis. This paper summarizes
the information used to conclude that high purity rebaudioside A (Rebiana)
produced to food-grade specifications and according to Good Manufacturing
Practices is safe for human consumption under its intended conditions of use as
a general purpose sweetener.
Effect on blood pressure, hypertension
The hemodynamic effects of rebaudioside A in healthy adults with normal and
low-normal blood pressure.
Food Chem Toxicol. 2008.
Rebaudioside A and stevioside are steviol glycosides extracted from the plant
Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni and are used in several countries as food and beverage
sweeteners. This randomized, double-blind trial evaluated the hemodynamic
effects of 4weeks consumption of 1000mg/day rebaudioside A vs. placebo in 100
individuals with normal and low-normal systolic blood pressure (SBP) and
diastolic blood pressure (DBP). Subjects were predominantly female (76%,
rebaudioside A and 82%, placebo) with a mean age of approximately 41 (range
18-73) years. At baseline, mean resting, seated SBP/DBP was 110/70 mmHg and
110 /71 mmHg for the rebaudioside A and placebo groups, respectively. Compared
with placebo, rebaudioside A did not significantly alter resting, seated SBP,
DBP, mean arterial pressure (MAP), heart rate (HR) or 24-h ambulatory blood
pressures responses. These results indicate that consumption of as much as
1000mg/day of rebaudioside A produced no clinically important changes in blood
pressure in healthy adults with normal and low-normal blood pressure.
A strong sustainability message and competitive pricing will be key to the
long-term success of Reb A, according to PureCircle corporate VP supply chain Dom Wenninger. Reb A
is likely to be fully competitive with sugar for global brands with global
volume. Dom
Wenninger illustrated the savings by comparing sugar and stevia prices. Sugar
prices in 2009 in the US are about $0.77 per kilo while Steviol glycosides, which are 15
times sweeter than sugar, are $0.40 per kilo on an equivalent basis. The
comparison may not be a favorable in all global markets since US sugar prices
are higher than most.
Following the decision in December 2008 by the US Food & Drug Administration to
certify Reb A as Generally Recognized as Safe, he said, product development
activity had been "intense." Dom Wenninger says, "To build on our continuing success, the global stevia industry
must work together as a sustainable industry to tell the very positive story
about stevia and the natural extraction methods used, which in many cases is
supporting some of the poorest farming communities. At PureCircle, we have learned from other sweeteners that the key
to a truly global success is to offer the sweetene r— Reb A — an all natural
alternative to sugar with zero calories — at a fully competitive price at the
earliest opportunity."
He said PureCircle, which has offices in New Jersey, Switzerland and Malaysia,
was in a strong position to achieve this thanks to its critical mass and its
global strategic collaborations with companies such as Firmenich. "This is a
monumental shift for the natural sweetener industry, which PureCircle is proud
to lead," he added.
Use in France in 2010
Even though stevia is not yet approved as an ingredient in the EU, the French
are taking advantage of a loophole that allows individual member states to
approve ingredient use for a two-year window. Though the European Food Safety
Authority (EFSA) has yet to offer an opinion on whether to approve Reb A and
stevia glycosides, the move may help companies gain market share while waiting
for final approval. Greensweet, the Auvergne-based company projects significant
number of French product launches using Reb-A starting in 2010. The French Food
Safety Agency (AFSSA) approved Reb-A, but not stevia glycosides. Consensus is
that France and the rest of the EU will wait for EFSA to approve the use of
steviol glycosides some time in 2010.
“Consumer concerns regarding obesity and the growing demand for all-natural products bode well for Reb A to quickly gain market share,” says Rabobank Food & Agribusiness Research and Advisory Executive Director Stephen Rannekleiv. ”However, while success seems imminent, and we expect annual U.S. sales of Reb A to reach approximately $700 million within 2015, numerous hurdles must still be overcome.” Reb A is an all-natural, non-caloric sweetener derived from the stevia plant. The stevia plant contains several sweet tasting glycosides, but it’s been found that Reb A has the closest taste profile to sugar. Since approved by the FDA, interest in the sweetener has surged, and is being used in products such as fruit juices, enhanced waters and carbonated soft drinks. Beverage companies are particularly interested because they are facing lagging sales of full-calorie soft drinks, and soft drinks made with artificial sweeteners because of consumer concerns. Reb A would allow companies to develop natural, low-calorie products made without artificial sweeteners.
Companies that sell stevia extract
products
Green Leaf Fields has 90 percent rebaudioside A or Reb-A. This company is based
out of Kauai, Hawaii.
PureCircle may be the worlds largest, or one of the largest stevia plant
producers. PureCircle supplies both Coca-Cola and Pepsi companies with stevia
extracts. The company has stevia plantations in China, Kenya and Paraguay, and
Vietnam.
In 2010 PureCircle South America SA (PCSA) and
the Cooperativa Colonias Unidas signed a contract for the production and supply
of stevia leaves. The event was held at the Cooperative headquarters in Obligado
and attended by managers and executives from both companies. Both PCSA and the
Cooperative are forging a strong commitment to develop the production of
proprietary varieties of high-quality stevia, to meet the growing international
demand for the all-natural, zero-calorie, stevia-based sweetener. The opening of
and access to large markets such as the USA, France, Australia, Switzerland and
Mexico, has increased the need for major development in the supply of dry
leaves.
Stevita
SweetLeaf
PureVia is PepsiCo's brand of Reb A sweetener, supplied by Pure Circle.
Pepsi has introduced PureVia to its SoBe drinks and an orange juice called
Trop50.
Reb A is made by Pure
Circle company.
Rebiana is the trade name for a zero-calorie sweetener containing mainly
rebaudioside A.
SweetLeaf has its own brand of stevia extract in packets and dissolving tablets.
Truvia is the consumer brand for Rebiana marketed by Cargill and developed
jointly with The Coca-Cola Company. Coke is using stevia (under the name Truvia)
in its Odwalla juice line and several flavors of Vitamin Water, along with
Sprite Green.
Truvia is supposed to be made from stevia and it's said to have no
aftertaste. But the word "made" is what has me nervous. My concern is that
because there is some manufacture involved, there may be some harmful side
effects. I'm wondering what your take on it is.
We have not seen significant human studies with Truvia
itself, but stevia is a safe sweetener.
Q. I recently got a newsletter regarding
the new "natural" zero-calorie sweetener. Can you comment on this? "Both Truvia
and PureVia are extracts of stevia leaves. Stevia leaves have been used for
centuries by other cultures, particularly in South America, to sweeten
beverages. But until recently, nobody has been using a purified concentrated
extract of the leaves, which is known as stevia or stevioside. The Coke and
Pepsi people rushed Truvia and PureVia through FDA approval, but many health
advocacy organizations, including the Center for Science in the Public Interest,
have voiced concerns that there are not significant studies to back up the
extracts’ safety. Morever, some of the studies that have been published on
stevia extracts are a little scary. For example, a recent study by Brazilian
researchers found that adding stevia extracts to the drinking water of lab rats
caused DNA breakage in cells in the animals' blood, liver, spleen, and brain.
(Food Chem Toxical, 2007) DNA damage may increase cancer risk. Until
significantly more studies are published that prove definitely that stevia is
safe, we recommend that you stick to a zero-calorie sweetener that has been
repeatedly proven to be safe."
A. We disagree. the small amounts of stevia extracts do not
appear to cause any problems and are safer than sugar. A person should have a
moderate intake, and as long as small to moderate amounts are used, we have no
reason to suspect any health issues.